19 Tough Questions Atheists Want to Ask People Who Believe in God

Written By Lisa Marley

Conversations between atheists and believers often raise some deep and challenging questions. These can be tricky to answer, especially when dealing with a skeptical audience. Here are 19 of those questions that atheists often ask those who believe in God.

Why Does Evil Exist?

Photo Credit: Shift Drive/Shutterstock

Atheists often ask why a loving and all-powerful God would allow so much suffering and evil in the world. If God is good, why do bad things happen? Believers usually point to the idea of free will, suggesting that people have the choice to do good or evil. Others, like Justia, point out that evil is considered a punishment against humanity.

How Do You Explain Natural Disasters?

Photo Credit: Shutterstock

When natural disasters like earthquakes and tsunamis occur, they cause immense suffering. Atheists wonder how these tragic events fit into the idea of a compassionate God. Christians might view these disasters as tests of faith or parts of a divine plan, but is that enough?

What About Contradictions in Holy Texts?

Photo Credit: SpeedKingz/Shutterstock

All holy books contain some passages that seem to contradict each other or feel outdated. That’s going to be an issue for atheists! Some religious people will interpret these texts metaphorically or say that deeper study resolves apparent contradictions, but for many atheists, these inconsistencies remain a major hurdle.

How Do You Reconcile Science and Faith?

Photo Credit: stockfour/Shutterstock

The worlds of science and religion sometimes seem at odds, especially on topics like evolution and the origin of the universe. This causes atheists to ask how believers reconcile these differences. Many people of faith see science and religion as addressing different kinds of questions, with science explaining the how and religion exploring the why.

Why Are There So Many Religions?

Photo Credit: loreanto/Shutterstock

There are so many different religions in the world, each with its own beliefs and practices. This variety leads atheists to wonder which, if any, is true. Believers say that all religions are different paths to the same ultimate truth, but this diversity can be confusing and lead to more questions than answers.

How Do You Know Your Religion Is Correct?

Photo Credit: fizkes/Shutterstock

Many believers are convinced that their religion is the one true faith. So anyone who isn’t religious could question how they can be so sure. This question gets to the heart of faith and the evidence that supports religious beliefs. Conviction alone doesn’t satisfy those who seek objective proof.

What Is the Evidence for God?

Photo Credit: Jacob Lund/Shutterstock

Atheists often ask for tangible evidence of God’s existence. Personal experiences, historical accounts, and philosophical arguments are common responses from people who believe in religion. However, these forms of evidence often don’t meet the empirical standards that atheists rely on, leaving them unconvinced.

Why Does God Require Worship?

Photo Credit: Shutterstock

The idea that an all-powerful deity needs worship raises some concerns for people trying to understand religion. Why would a perfect being want or need human praise? It could be the case that worship is more about the spiritual growth of the worshiper than fulfilling any need of God, but the question still puzzles many.

How Do You Explain Miracles?

Photo Credit: Shutterstock

Miracles are often explained as evidence of divine intervention, yet they defy natural laws. Atheists look for natural explanations and remain skeptical of miraculous claims. Believers see miracles as rare, significant signs of God’s presence, but proving these events to skeptics is challenging.

What Happens to Those Who Don’t Believe?

Photo Credit: Ground Picture/Shutterstock

Many religious doctrines suggest that non-believers face negative consequences after death. People who don’t want to be religious naturally find this pretty troubling and question the justice of punishing people for their lack of belief. It’s a scary thought, for sure.

Why Is Faith Necessary?

Photo Credit: Rawpixel.com/Shutterstock

The idea of faith is a central concept in many religions, but atheists often see it as belief without evidence. They wonder why faith is considered a virtue and why a benevolent God would require it. There might be an argument that faith fosters trust and a deeper relationship with the divine.

How Do You Address Religious Hypocrisy?

Photo Credit: Dmytro Zinkevych/Shutterstock

Hypocrisy among religious leaders and followers challenges the credibility of religious institutions. This causes atheists to ask believers how they reconcile their faith with the actions of those who violate its principles. And that’s a tricky thing to answer.

What About Historical Injustices?

Photo Credit: Antonio Guillem/Shutterstock

Religion has been associated with various historical injustices, such as wars and persecution. Atheists question how a benevolent God could allow such actions in His name. Believers often distinguish between human misuse of religion and the true teachings of their faith, though this distinction doesn’t erase the troubling history.

Why Are There Unanswered Prayers?

Photo Credit: Antonio Guillem/Shutterstock

Any prayers that go unanswered challenge the belief in a responsive and caring God. Many people wonder why a loving God would ignore sincere requests for help, which is reasonable. The answer could be that unanswered prayers serve a higher purpose or that God’s wisdom transcends human understanding.

How Do You Handle Doubt?

Photo Credit: MAD.vertise/Shutterstock

Even devout believers experience moments of doubt and uncertainty. As such, people who don’t believe are curious about how they manage these doubts while maintaining their faith. Many people of faith view doubt as a natural part of spiritual growth, using it as an opportunity for deeper reflection and understanding.

Why Is There a Lack of Consensus Among Believers?

Photo Credit: New Africa/Shutterstock

Even within the same religion, significant disagreements about beliefs and practices exist. Why is a divine truth so open to interpretation? Perhaps it could be that the diversity of thought enriches the faith of religious people, but it can also be a source of confusion and conflict.

How Do You Explain the Success of Secular Societies?

Photo Credit: Prostock-studio/Shutterstock

Some of the most prosperous and peaceful societies are mainly secular, challenging the notion that belief in God is essential for morality and well-being. Atheists ask why these societies thrive without religious guidance. Believers might attribute this success to other factors, but the question remains intriguing.

What Role Does Culture Play in Religion?

Photo Credit: Antonio Guillem/Shutterstock

The close relationship between culture and religion always raises questions about the origins of religious beliefs. Many atheists wonder how much of faith is influenced by cultural context rather than divine truth. Believers often acknowledge the cultural aspects of religion while maintaining that its core truths are universal.

How Do You Justify Religious Exclusivity?

Photo Credit: fizkes/Shutterstock

Many religions claim to be the only true path to God, which atheists find exclusionary and divisive. This causes them to question the fairness and logic of a system where only certain believers are deemed worthy of salvation. Religious types might emphasize the inclusive aspects of their faith, but the issue remains contentious.

Up Next: 18 Reasons Why Men Get Grumpier As They Age

Photo Credit: Krakenimages.com/Shutterstock

You might read this and be able to relate, or you may feel you’ve become grumpier the older you’ve gotten. Or maybe you know of a male friend or relative who has. Here are 18 reasons why men get grumpier as they age.

18 Reasons Why Men Get Grumpier As They Age

17 Products Millennials Refuse to Buy and It’s Affecting the Economy

Photo Credit: Stockbakery/Shutterstock

Millennials have been the center of so much media attention due to their spending habits. Their unique ways of spending have built up and crushed many traditional industries. In this article, we look at 17 things millennials stopped buying and how that has impacted society.

17 Products Millennials Refuse to Buy and It’s Affecting the Economy

Where Even Truck Drivers Won’t Stop

Photo Credit: Jacob Boomsma/Shutterstock

Truck drivers tend to be hardy souls—well-seasoned travelers who aren’t often afraid to rest up or refuel in risky locations. However, there are certain U.S. locations that even the most road-weary trucker refuses to stop at for fear of criminal activity or natural dangers. Here are 17 such locations that even experienced truck drivers approach with trepidation (or not at all).

17 PLACES IN THE U.S. WHERE EVEN TRUCK DRIVERS WON’T STOP